
















Tom Humpage, judge: I like the comedy aspect of this image - it's well caught. I'd have liked the pengiun to be a little more to the right and to not have the top of the rock cropped off. Despite this it's a creative take on the theme and a lively capture. Photograph: Pauline Litton

Tom Humpage, judge: What a brilliant shot - it practically moves! You can taste the sea spray and feel the cold of the water. Totally spontaneous and well captured in that split second. The colours and light are fantastic. My one issue is the two people on the right, who detract from the theme of solitude - I'd have liked them to be cropped out. But otherwise a really fantastic image. Photograph: Nicole Carman

Tom Humpage, judge: The photographer has created solitude using light which is unusual among this shortlist. I like the way she is staring into the camera so you know it's a genuine facial expression rather than a fleeting tick the camera has captured. The young girl is singled out, which makes you think about what destiny has in store. Great composition – a shot to be proud of. Photograph: Laura Cook
